Sam Bennett's Goalie Interference: A Growing Concern for the NHL

By Emil Champlin

As the Florida Panthers advance through the 2025 Stanley Cup Playoffs, forward Sam Bennett's aggressive playstyle has come under intense scrutiny. Repeated incidents involving goaltender interference have raised questions about player safety and the NHL's disciplinary consistency.

A Pattern of Controversy

Bennett's physical approach has long been a hallmark of his game, but recent events suggest a troubling pattern. In Game 1 of the second-round series against the Toronto Maple Leafs, Bennett delivered a high elbow to goaltender Anthony Stolarz, resulting in Stolarz vomiting on the bench and being stretchered off the ice. Despite the severity of the incident, Bennett faced no suspension, sparking outrage among fans and commentators. 

This was not an isolated event. During the 2024 playoffs, Bennett scored a controversial goal against the Boston Bruins after pushing Bruins forward Charlie Coyle into goaltender Jeremy Swayman. The goal stood after review, despite clear evidence of interference.

Most recently, in Game 2 of the Stanley Cup Final against the Edmonton Oilers, Bennett collided with goaltender Stuart Skinner, resulting in a goaltender interference penalty. Bennett expressed surprise at the call, stating that Skinner had kicked his heel. 

NHL's Disciplinary Inconsistencies

The NHL's response to Bennett's actions has been inconsistent. While he was fined $5,000 for roughing Pittsburgh Penguins forward Drew O'Connor in January 2025, more severe incidents involving goaltender interference have gone unpunished. This disparity has led to accusations of a double standard in the league's disciplinary actions.

Critics argue that the NHL's failure to penalize Bennett appropriately undermines its commitment to player safety. The lack of consistent enforcement sends a message that dangerous plays, particularly against goaltenders, may be tolerated during high-stakes games.

The Impact on the Game

Bennett's actions not only endanger opposing players but also tarnish the integrity of the sport. Goaltenders, often in vulnerable positions, rely on the league to enforce rules that protect them. When these protections are not upheld, it sets a dangerous precedent and erodes trust in the system.

As the playoffs continue, the NHL faces mounting pressure to address these concerns. Ensuring fair play and player safety must remain paramount to preserve the sport's integrity and protect its athletes.

Emil Champlin is a  freelance writer for Veritas Expositae

You can reach him at emil.champlin@veritasexpositae.com